Crown land has significant spiritual, social, cultural and economic importance to the Aboriginal people of NSW. There are various legal mechanisms in place to protect places and objects of heritage significance to Aboriginal people, and provide access or title to Crown lands in certain circumstances.
The following section outlines information on native Title, Aboriginal land rights and Aboriginal heritage considerations. We also showcase some case studies on Western Bundjalung people and Mothers Ancestral Guardians Indigenous Corporation.
Native title is the name Australian law gives to the traditional ownership of land and waters that have always belonged to Aboriginal people according to their traditions, laws and customs. The Commonwealth Native Title Act 1993 (NT Act) sets out how native title rights are to be recognised and protected.
The department is committed to managing Crown land consistently with the NT Act. This responsibility also extends to Crown land managers (CLMs).
Native title rights are different to, and separate from, the statutory right of Aboriginal Land Councils to make claims for land under the NSW Aboriginal Land Rights Act 1983 (ALR Act).
Land rights are granted in the form of freehold land where the minister administering the NSW Crown Land Management Act 2016 (CLM Act) determines that the land is ‘claimable land’ for the purposes of the ALR Act. Read more about Aboriginal land rights and Crown land.
Native title might exist on your reserve. Where it does, the basis on which the reserve was established remains valid, and the use of the reserve for the specified reserve purpose takes precedence over any native title rights that may exist on the land after its reservation and the establishment of the Crown land manager.
This means that if Crown land is reserved as a park, beach or nature reserve, say, and the public has the right to access this land, this right cannot be taken away by native title. Native title would be non-exclusive, meaning that existing uses continue alongside activities permitted by native title holders (such as hunting, cultural events, camping).
Responsibilities regarding native title vary among different types of CLM. There are three categories of CLMs:
Council and category 1 CLMs are responsible for compliance with native title legislation.
This means they must ensure their dealings and activities on Crown reserves they manage comply with the NT Act. Council and category 1 CLMs must employ or engage a native title manager to ensure compliance with the NT Act.
Category 2 CLMs generally cannot undertake dealings or activities that might impact native title without ministerial oversight. Therefore native title compliance for category 2 CLMs rests with the department.
A native title manager is a person who has undertaken approved training or qualifications and is engaged or employed by a council or category 1 CLM to advise on native title compliance.
Native title managers must provide written advice to the CLM about dealings or activities on Crown reserves that might affect native title.
Where the native title manager is uncertain about the native title implications, they must seek legal advice. If this is not possible, the proposed activity shouldn't proceed.
The department cannot provide advice to native title managers on native title compliance.
The Native title manager workbook has been designed to guide and assist native title managers in understanding their tasks and responsibilities as part of day-to-day work as a CLM.
This workbook provides support to Council and Category 1 CLMs to confidently fulfil their stewardship role over the Crown land they manage and avoid any risk of unintended outcomes and liabilities.
The workbook also provides information on the significance of native title and why it is important to Aboriginal people and their communities. This will continue to enhance and strengthen relationships with Aboriginal communities, which will in turn benefit the economic and social outcomes of council and category 1 CLMs. For more information, download the Native title manager workbook.
As a general rule, the reservation or dedication of land for a public purpose does not extinguish (remove or void) all native title rights and interests in the land. However, it might extinguish some rights.
Whether native title exists over a piece of land is a matter for determination by the Federal Court of Australia. The court can determine that native title exists, or does not exist, based on evidence of continuing connection with the land or waters or a valid inconsistent tenure.
Even if there has been no determination of native title or no claim lodged in respect of the land on your reserve, native title might still exist.
Therefore, until there is a native title determination for your reserve you must assume native title exists and manage your activities in compliance with the NT Act.
You may be able to apply for a native title certificate. CLMs and native title managers are not qualified to decide that native title has been extinguished.
The act of making a native title claim confers no special rights on the applicants. However, if the claim passes the registration test provided for in the NT Act, the applicants are granted certain rights. Those rights include the right to receive notice and to comment on some proposed acts—for example, building, grazing or clearing vegetation—that may affect native title. Even if there is no registered native title claim, there may still be a requirement to give notice of particular acts to any representative Aboriginal/Torres Strait Islander body in relation to the area (the representative body). For New South Wales, the representative body is NTSCORP.
A CLM might be notified by the National Native Title Tribunal that a claim has been lodged. If so, the CLM can apply to become a party to the Federal Court proceedings. However, before doing so you should consult the department, as being a party could be both time-consuming and costly. The minister responsible for Crown Lands is responsible for managing claim applications affecting land and water in NSW and is a party to every claim. Accordingly, the minister might be in a position to represent the CLM’s interests.
CLMs might be asked to provide information concerning the use and management of the reserve and the public works that exist on it, to help the minister in the negotiation of the claim and also in any court proceedings. In some cases, you might be asked to help the minister to negotiate outcomes and to play an active role in those negotiations.
If the Federal Court determines that native title exists on a piece of land, the NSW Government will attempt to negotiate an indigenous land use agreement (ILUA) that addresses any land management issues with respect to the public lands covered by the determination or recognition.
If native title has not been extinguished over the land making up a reserve, the CLM must not undertake any activity that would ‘affect’ native title unless it is done in compliance with the NT Act. Under the NT Act, an action ‘affects’ native title if it could extinguish any native title that exists, or if it is inconsistent with the ‘continued existence, enjoyment or exercise of native title rights and interests’.
Some common acts on a reserve that might affect native title include:
Council CLMs or category 1 CLMs must seek written advice from their native title manager before they undertake an act that might affect native title.
The Native title manager workbook provides detailed guidance and assistance for dealing with scenarios where native title has not been extinguished.
The department cannot provide advice on native title compliance. If there is any doubt about compliance with the NTA then you should seek legal advice.
A native title certificate is a document issued by the department that indicates, to the best of the department’s knowledge, that there is adequate evidence that native title has been extinguished or does not exist. The ability to issue native title certificates is a new provision in the CLM Act.
Native title certificates will only be issued in limited circumstances.
Native title certificates, if issued, will state that 'there is adequate evidence to show that native title rights and interests in relation to the land have been extinguished or do not exist'. This is not the same as a determination of native title, which can only be made by the Federal Court. A native title certificate has the effect that a council or category 1 CLM does not need to seek written advice from their native title manager before they undertake an act that might affect native title, but any requirements of native title legislation are unaffected by the issuing of a native title certificate.
Native title certificates are issued at the absolute discretion of the minister and can be revoked. Although it is expected that revoking a certificate will be rare, it may occur if a native title determination specifies a different outcome than anticipated. Further information will be available in mid-2019.
The Aboriginal Land Rights Act 1983 (ALR Act) is important legislation that provides land rights for Aboriginal people in NSW. The lodgement of an Aboriginal land claim by a Land Council creates what is known as an inchoate (unformed) interest in the land. The full extent of that interest is not known until the claim is investigated and a determination is made by the relevant Minister.
Further information regarding the ALR Act can be found on the department’s website.
In circumstances where CLMs are undertaking significant new works on the land they manage, they should check for the presence of any undetermined Aboriginal land claims.
This check can be done through the department's Aboriginal Land Claim Investigation Unit. Please contact the department for advice.
All Aboriginal objects and places are protected in NSW under the National Parks and Wildlife Act 1974 (NPW Act). Amendments to the NPW Act in October 2010 introduced increased penalties and strict liability offences for harming Aboriginal objects and places.
It is an offence to damage known Aboriginal heritage, unless the work is listed in the legislation as ‘exempt’. Therefore it is important to continually check the Aboriginal Heritage Information Management System (AHIMS), maintained by the government, for locations of known Aboriginal heritage.
Such heritage is categorised as either an ‘Aboriginal object’ or an ‘Aboriginal place’. Work that may affect such objects and places requires an Aboriginal Heritage Impact Permit from the department.
It is an offence to harm (even unintentionally) Aboriginal heritage that was not known (except where the work is listed in the legislation as ‘exempt’ or ‘low impact’, or the harm resulted in something ‘trivial’ or ‘negligible’), unless it can be demonstrated that a process of ‘due diligence’ was undertaken prior to any work to determine whether such heritage might exist.
Therefore, a due diligence investigation should be undertaken prior to any work (other than work listed in the legislation as ‘exempt’ or ‘low impact’) in areas likely to contain unknown Aboriginal heritage to determine whether such heritage might exist.
To assist compliance with the legislation the department has prepared a Due Diligence Code of Practice for the Protection of Aboriginal Objects in NSW. This document also includes descriptions of common types of Aboriginal objects that may be encountered.
This Crown land manager web resource was printed on 17 Dec 2019. The information contained in this web resource is based on knowledge and understanding at the time of writing Dec 2019. However, because of advances in knowledge, users are reminded of the need to ensure that the information upon which they rely is up to date and to check the currency of the information by referring to the website (www.reservemanager.nsw.gov.au).
© State of New South Wales through Department of Planning, Industry & Environment 2019.
Page link: https://reservemanager.crownland.nsw.gov.au/land-management/aboriginal-interests